It was February 2003 and America had just invaded Iraq. Protests had broken out across the country railing against Bush and his cronies for the misguided military action. The biggest one was to be staged in New York City the upcoming weekend. And I would be there, right in the heart of Manhattan, much to the envy of my liberal friends. I didn’t have the heart to tell them the true purpose of my trip.
I was invited to be a judge of the Miss New York City pageant, one of the tributaries that dumps its glitzy treasures into Atlantic City for the ultimate prize: Miss America. Now understand, I have zero credentials. Nada. Zilch. At the time I was selling newspaper subscriptions over the phone while cranking out screenplays, a typical LA scene. And it’s not like I had a lot of experience with women. Hardly any, in fact (still don’t). Heck, I only had one girlfriend- and that was in college, for chrissakes. What’s more, I don’t like to judge anyone, least of all beautiful, talented girls who were a decade younger and light years out of my league. Truth is, I had no business attending a beauty pageant, let alone judging one.
Her name was Merry, the girlfriend of my college buddy Steve. The quirky spelling of her name proved apropos upon meeting the bubbly blonde, who bore more than a passing resemblance to Reese Witherspoon. I bumped into the handsome couple at Duke’s in Malibu on my way to the bathroom. They urged me to join them, so I did. We proceeded to drink heavily, swapping stories. Merry seemed to be intrigued by me- not sexually, but in a kindred, creative soul kind of way. She was, after all, a professional harp player. Thanks to the slew of margaritas, I was ‘on’ that night, a rare display of my latent charms. Merry headed the Miss New York City pageant- she was on a million charity boards- and one of the judges had just backed out. Despite my utter lack of credentials, she thought I would be a good fit. We exchanged numbers and, at the end of the evening, a warm embrace.
A week later, Merry mailed me a thick binder, a dossier of the two dozen young women competing in the pageant. The resumes of these girls, all between the ages of 18 and 24, were impressive, even if they were a bit doctored. Every one of them attended prominent colleges, possessed an arsenal of extraordinary skills, and volunteered for every charity known to mankind. But who was I to judge? (no, really). I’d have to spruce up my resume, too. Believe me, no one wants their fate decided by a telemarketer.
I brought the binder to work, flaunting my elevated status as a pageant judge. My friends pointed out their favorite girls, oohing and aahing in between cold calls. They assumed that, as a judge, I would be able to sleep with any of them. And truth be told, the thought dangled in my mind, as well. My leftist co-workers stopped by my cubicle and heaped praise on me for protesting Bush’s illegal war. I nodded, stuffing the binder in my backpack.
Much to my disappointment, no one on the plane commented on the binder. It rested squarely on my lap, the bold-faced font screaming ‘2003 MISS NEW YORK CITY PAGEANT.’ Perhaps because I was seated near the rear bathroom, scarfing down free peanuts with the vengeance of a meth addict, I was not mistaken for a celebrity. Oh, well. I still had an entire weekend in Manhattan to fool other people, particularly the contestants. I was listed in the judge’s biography as a music video director. Now, I did work on dozens of music videos, so it wasn’t a total lie. I was the guy who fetched coffee for the actual director, among other humiliating tasks. Fortunately, Google hadn’t really taken off yet, so my falsehoods would likely go undetected.
Later that night, Merry got us into an underground party in Midtown Manhattan. The venue was a converted warehouse packed with the city’s hippest young socialites. The first thing you saw stepping through the entrance was a gigantic porno being projected onto the wall. I felt as if I had stumbled onto the Eyes Wide Shut set. In one roped off corner of the room, an 18-year-old Playboy model was doling out lap dances. Merry brought me over. She introduced me as one of the pageant judges and the model lit up. She performed an exotic dance, grinding on my crotch, eyeing my lustfully. Before she finished, she declared that Merry and I would have sex that night. We both maintained that we were just friends.
Merry lived on the Upper West Side, north of 100th street, where the swankiness morphs into sketchiness. It was a three bedroom apartment that she shared with two male friends. After the party- and a healthy amount of cocktails- we returned to her place. I laid down on the couch, my sleeping quarters for the weekend. Merry freshened up in the bathroom, then proceeded to sit next to me. Heck, she was practically on top of me. She insisted that I stay in her room, that her bed was much more comfortable. I declined the offer, saying the couch was fine. This parrying went on for at least ten minutes. Now, I have to say, I was tempted. Blondes aren’t really my type, especially ones with blue eyes, but she was more than pretty enough. And I was more than drunk enough… I couldn’t do that to Steve, though. So I remained steadfast in my refusal. Finally, she relented and stalked off to her bedroom. I heaved a sigh of relief, not sure if I should mention any of this to Steve.
The next day, my fellow judges and I interviewed the contestants at some meeting hall in the Meatpacking District. There were six of us, all from various backgrounds. Thankfully, none of them were employed in the entertainment industry. Merry stood to the side, occasionally throwing amorous glances my way, as the interviews began. This segment of the competition accounted for a third of the score. The girls came out and stood in front of us, one after another, enduring a barrage of questions for about five minutes or so. They were generally of the softball variety: “What’s your favorite film?” and so forth.
Considering the protests nearby, there were a few queries regarding the invasion of Iraq. The girls possessed incredible poise, well practiced in the art of fielding questions. And they were as beautiful as the black and white photos in the binders. I asked one of the contestants, “What’s your favorite Beatles song?” She appropriately responded that you couldn’t really pick just one. Grinning sheepishly, I stayed silent for the rest of her turn.
Afterwards, the judges and the pageant staff, including Merry, had dinner. Unfortunately, the contestants would not be joining us. They would be sequestered, eliminating any chance of cavorting with a judge. Alas, my co-workers’ fantasies (and mine) would not come to fruition. The big show was tomorrow, so Merry and I kept the drinking to a minimum that evening. The previous night was not mentioned and there was no further offerings of a bed. I laid on the couch, bummed about failing to capitalize on my position as a judge.
The pageant was held at an YMCA auditorium in Midtown. A few hundred spectators, mostly friends and family of the contestants, filled the small arena. A friend of Merry’s almost blew my cover. A short, bearded hobbit of a man peppered me with questions about directing music videos. I humbly deflected them, claiming ‘it was no big deal.’ Thankfully, the pageant had begun and I took my seat at the judge’s table.
The first event was the talent competition. One of the girls, a slightly overweight African-American, crooned an opera song that blew everyone away. She was amazingly talented, having done exceptionally well in the interviews, as well. A few others sang, a few danced. One performed an acting scene, one juggled. My personal favorite- and I think I speak for my fellow judges, who all happened to be male- was the belly dancer, who gyrated her sexy little body at the edge of the stage, right in front of us. It took incredible restraint not to fling a dollar bill at her.
Next was the swimsuit competition. And this proved to be the downfall of the opera singer. I’m not being sexist here, believe me. She was at least 30 pounds overweight, not exactly the body type that captures the Miss America title. And that’s what we were searching for, the girl with the best chance to win the whole thing. This portion of the show winnowed the field to just a handful of candidates. Jessica Lynch seemed to be the front runner. She aced the interview, had a solid dancing routine, and looked fantastic in a bikini. I mean, she looked like a pageant winner. Interestingly, she shared the name of the Iraq war hero who was rescued around that time.
The final segment was the evening wear competition. Here the girls were judged on their poise, along with their (well rehearsed) answers as to what they would do as pageant winners. Everyone was terrific, racking up near perfect scores. Fairly or not, it was the swimsuit deal that would decide this affair. It was no surprise to anyone when a crown was placed on Jessica’s well-coiffed head.
The judges and staff met Jessica afterwards, congratulating her. I gushed something incoherent to her, unable to muster the charm I unleashed on Merry that night at Duke’s… Jessica was stunning. My type, too, a petite brunette. Those girls generally don’t win the big prizes, though. And sure enough, six months later in Atlantic City, she failed to make the first cut.
Back in Los Angeles, I was revered at my crappy job. Everyone asked about the pageant. I regaled them with tales of the Eyes Wide Shut party and the belly dancer, among other highlights. My liberal cohorts excitedly asked me about the protests. I told them that I had, as a matter of fact, met Jessica Lynch. I shook her hand and spoke with her and everything. “Is she against the war?” they inquired, eagerly anticipating my answer. I tried to recall the interview session with her. “I don’t know. I didn’t ask.”